Home

Lost Dutchman Rare Coins has been the premier full service coin shop in Indianapolis since 1983. We specialize in buying and selling collectible coins, paper money, and bullion. As a family run local business we value our customers. Your satisfaction is our number one priority whether it’s selling to us or adding to your collection. We offer the following services.

  • FREE in office appraisals.
  • Numismatic Consulting.
  • PCGS, PMG, NGC, & CAC submission center.
  • Gold, Silver, Platinum, Palladium buyers and sellers.
  • Top Prices Paid For Broken and Unused Gold & Silver Jewelry

Our award winning staff has over 160 years of numismatic experience. Matt Dinger has been a collector since childhood and is featured on The Coin Show Podcast. Evan Munden is a bright and talented numismatist who is focused on helping collectors add the right coins to their collection.

We offer FREE appraisal services in the store. Walk ins are always welcome. Stop in today to view our current inventory!