Homepage | Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Meet Our Team

Spencer Sallee

Numismatist

Matt Dinger

Senior Numismatist

Cory Williams

Paper Money Expert / Ancient Coins

Featured Coins

View All

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

1783-Restrike Post Colonial Issues Washington Portrait Pieces - Copper Cent PCGS PR-64 BN Washington Draped

$950.00

1904 $2.50 Gold Liberty Head Quarter Eagle NGC MS-67+

$4,750.00

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

1783-Restrike Post Colonial Issues Washington Portrait Pieces - Copper Cent PCGS PR-64 BN Washington Draped

$950.00

1904 $2.50 Gold Liberty Head Quarter Eagle NGC MS-67+

$4,750.00

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

New Purchases

View All

1957-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 RB

$275.00

1934 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse NGC AU-55 STRUCK 15% OFF CENTER

$125.00

1941 Mercury Dime PCGS AU-50 Struck 25% Off Center

$750.00

1956-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-63 Struck 65% Off Center

$250.00

1930-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS AU-58 Struck 20% Off Center

$325.00

1928-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS VF-25 Struck 10% Off Center

$200.00

1957-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 Struck 60% Off Center

$250.00

1942-S Nickel Jefferson PCGS MS-66

$45.00

1904 $2.50 Gold Liberty Head Quarter Eagle NGC MS-67+

$4,750.00

1911 CHINA Silver DOLLAR PCGS XF Details - Chopmark LM-37A w/o Dot & Flame

$4,500.00

1934 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-63 Uncentered Broadstrike BN

$200.00

1934 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-65 Broadstruck RB

$300.00

1951-S Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-62 Struck 5% Off Center BN

$225.00

1924 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS VF-20 Struck 10% Off Center BN

$200.00

1919 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS XF-45 BN Broadstruck

$140.00

1957-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 RB

$275.00

1934 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse NGC AU-55 STRUCK 15% OFF CENTER

$125.00

1941 Mercury Dime PCGS AU-50 Struck 25% Off Center

$750.00

1956-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-63 Struck 65% Off Center

$250.00

1930-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS AU-58 Struck 20% Off Center

$325.00

1928-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS VF-25 Struck 10% Off Center

$200.00

1957-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 Struck 60% Off Center

$250.00

1942-S Nickel Jefferson PCGS MS-66

$45.00

1904 $2.50 Gold Liberty Head Quarter Eagle NGC MS-67+

$4,750.00

1911 CHINA Silver DOLLAR PCGS XF Details - Chopmark LM-37A w/o Dot & Flame

$4,500.00

1934 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-63 Uncentered Broadstrike BN

$200.00

1934 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-65 Broadstruck RB

$300.00

1951-S Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-62 Struck 5% Off Center BN

$225.00

1924 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS VF-20 Struck 10% Off Center BN

$200.00

1919 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS XF-45 BN Broadstruck

$140.00

1957-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 RB

$275.00

Most Active Gold Bullion

View All

Most Active Silver Bullion

View All

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $40.44

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $439.42

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $40.44

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $439.42

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $40.44

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $439.42

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $40.44

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $439.42

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $40.44

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $439.42

Recently Purchased Notes

View All

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1928A $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note, Woods-Mellon sigs

$140.00

Ch AU Fr. 37 1917 $1 United States Note, Elliot-Burke sigs, K-A block

$375.00

Ch. 1032 1929 Ty. I $10 The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$120.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Minneapolis district Federal Reserve Note

$140.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Cleveland district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Philadelphia district Federal Reserve Note

$140.00

Series 1934 Yellow Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$125.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1928A $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note, Woods-Mellon sigs

$140.00

Ch AU Fr. 37 1917 $1 United States Note, Elliot-Burke sigs, K-A block

$375.00

Ch. 1032 1929 Ty. I $10 The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$120.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Minneapolis district Federal Reserve Note

$140.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Cleveland district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Philadelphia district Federal Reserve Note

$140.00

Series 1934 Yellow Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$125.00

Series 1934 Dark Green Seal $100 Chicago district Federal Reserve Note

$130.00

National Notes

View All

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch. 708 1929 Ty. I $10 The Millers River National Bank of Athol, Massachusetts

$150.00

Ch. 5076 1929 Ty. I $20 The City National Bank of Logansport, Indiana

$185.00

Ch. 5524 1929 Ty. I $20 The First National Bank of Russiaville, Indiana

$1,400.00

Ch. 1032 1929 Ty. I $10 The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch. 708 1929 Ty. I $10 The Millers River National Bank of Athol, Massachusetts

$150.00

Ch. 5076 1929 Ty. I $20 The City National Bank of Logansport, Indiana

$185.00

Ch. 5524 1929 Ty. I $20 The First National Bank of Russiaville, Indiana

$1,400.00

Ch. 1032 1929 Ty. I $10 The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00

Ch AU Ch. 4652 1929 Ty. I $20 The Seymour National Bank, Seymour, Indiana

$400.00