Homepage | Lost Dutchman Rare Coins

Meet Our Team

Spencer Sallee

Numismatist

Matt Dinger

Senior Numismatist

Cory Williams

Paper Money Expert / Ancient Coins

Featured Coins

View All

1916 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial PCGS MS-64 McKinley

$650.00

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

1783-Restrike Post Colonial Issues Washington Portrait Pieces - Copper Cent PCGS PR-64 BN Washington Draped

$950.00

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1916 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial PCGS MS-64 McKinley

$650.00

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

1783-Restrike Post Colonial Issues Washington Portrait Pieces - Copper Cent PCGS PR-64 BN Washington Draped

$950.00

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1916 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial PCGS MS-64 McKinley

$650.00

1935-RCM CANADA Silver DOLLAR PCGS MS-67

$2,900.00

1984-S Modern Commemorative Los Angeles Olympiad PCGS PR-66 DCAM Olympic TONED

$600.00

New Purchases

View All

1909-S Small Cents Indian Head NGC XF-45 BN

$575.00

1895-Do, RS MEXICO Silver PESO ANACS MS-62

$350.00

1900-Zs, FZ MEXICO Silver PESO ANACS AU-58

$165.00

1922 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse NGC F-12 BN STRONG REVERSE

$750.00

2014-S Half Dollars Kennedy PCGS MS-70 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State Moy Signature

$150.00

1968 MEXICO Silver 25 PESOS PCGS MS-67 Olympic Type 1 KM-479.1

$65.00

1948-D Quarter Dollars Silver Coinage PCGS MS-66

$50.00

1899 Quarter Dollars Barber or Liberty Head ANACS VF-30

$55.00

1891-CC Gold Half Eagles Liberty Head PCGS AU-55

$2,050.00

1809 Capped Bust Half Dollars PCGS VG-10

$175.00

1921 Peace Silver Dollar PCGS XF-45 Peace

$210.00

1942-D Mercury Dime NGC VF-35 /41

$550.00

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1916 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial PCGS MS-64 McKinley

$650.00

1931-S Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 RB

$220.00

1909-S Small Cents Indian Head NGC XF-45 BN

$575.00

1895-Do, RS MEXICO Silver PESO ANACS MS-62

$350.00

1900-Zs, FZ MEXICO Silver PESO ANACS AU-58

$165.00

1922 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse NGC F-12 BN STRONG REVERSE

$750.00

2014-S Half Dollars Kennedy PCGS MS-70 50th Anniversary Set, Silver, Enhanced Mint State Moy Signature

$150.00

1968 MEXICO Silver 25 PESOS PCGS MS-67 Olympic Type 1 KM-479.1

$65.00

1948-D Quarter Dollars Silver Coinage PCGS MS-66

$50.00

1899 Quarter Dollars Barber or Liberty Head ANACS VF-30

$55.00

1891-CC Gold Half Eagles Liberty Head PCGS AU-55

$2,050.00

1809 Capped Bust Half Dollars PCGS VG-10

$175.00

1921 Peace Silver Dollar PCGS XF-45 Peace

$210.00

1942-D Mercury Dime NGC VF-35 /41

$550.00

1917 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial NGC MS-66 MCKINLEY CAC

$1,850.00

1916 Classic Commemorative McKinley Memorial PCGS MS-64 McKinley

$650.00

1931-S Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-64 RB

$220.00

1909-S Small Cents Indian Head NGC XF-45 BN

$575.00

Most Active Gold Bullion

View All

Most Active Silver Bullion

View All

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $38.12

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $416.20

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $38.12

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $416.20

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $38.12

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $416.20

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $38.12

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $416.20

1oz Generic Silver Round

As low as $38.12

10oz Generic Silver Bar

As low as $416.20

Recently Purchased Notes

View All

Ch. 8835 1929 Ty. I $20 The Birdseye National Bank, Birdseye, Indiana GREAT NAME

$500.00

PMG Fine 12 Ch. 5845 1882 $5 BB Columbia NB of Indianapolis, IN Quite Scarce!

$1,600.00

PMG VF30 Ch. 7260 1902 $10 PB The First National Bank of Odon, Indiana

$1,300.00

Ch. 8149 1902 $5 PB The Bozeman Waters National Bank of Poseyville, Indiana

$800.00

PMG VF20 Ch. 13759 1929 Ty. II $50 American National Bank of Indianapolis, IN

$550.00

PMG VF25 Ch. 7863 1929 $10 Ty. I The First National Bank of Goodland, Indiana

$400.00

Ch. 1032 1929 $5 Ty. I The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$325.00

Ch. 9401 1929 Ty. I $10 The First National Bank of Cannelton, Indiana

$250.00

after 1864 Dr. Seth Arnold's Cough Killer Woonsocket, Rhode Island Ad Note

$125.00

RARE Ch. 7174 1902 PB $10 The First National Bank of Williamsburg, Kentucky

$1,500.00

Nice UNC Series 1953B $5 Star Note United States Note

$200.00

Nice UNC Series 1963 $5 Star Note United States Note

$100.00

Series 1928F Wide $5 Star Note United States Note, Nice original AU here

$385.00

Fr. 1173 1922 $10 Gold Certificate, Speelman-White sigs, Michael Hillegas portrait

$185.00

PCGS Currency Choice AU 58 Fr. 991a 1914 $20 Chicago Federal Reserve Note, NICE!

$700.00

Ch. 8835 1929 Ty. I $20 The Birdseye National Bank, Birdseye, Indiana GREAT NAME

$500.00

PMG Fine 12 Ch. 5845 1882 $5 BB Columbia NB of Indianapolis, IN Quite Scarce!

$1,600.00

PMG VF30 Ch. 7260 1902 $10 PB The First National Bank of Odon, Indiana

$1,300.00

Ch. 8149 1902 $5 PB The Bozeman Waters National Bank of Poseyville, Indiana

$800.00

PMG VF20 Ch. 13759 1929 Ty. II $50 American National Bank of Indianapolis, IN

$550.00

PMG VF25 Ch. 7863 1929 $10 Ty. I The First National Bank of Goodland, Indiana

$400.00

Ch. 1032 1929 $5 Ty. I The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$325.00

Ch. 9401 1929 Ty. I $10 The First National Bank of Cannelton, Indiana

$250.00

after 1864 Dr. Seth Arnold's Cough Killer Woonsocket, Rhode Island Ad Note

$125.00

RARE Ch. 7174 1902 PB $10 The First National Bank of Williamsburg, Kentucky

$1,500.00

Nice UNC Series 1953B $5 Star Note United States Note

$200.00

Nice UNC Series 1963 $5 Star Note United States Note

$100.00

Series 1928F Wide $5 Star Note United States Note, Nice original AU here

$385.00

Fr. 1173 1922 $10 Gold Certificate, Speelman-White sigs, Michael Hillegas portrait

$185.00

PCGS Currency Choice AU 58 Fr. 991a 1914 $20 Chicago Federal Reserve Note, NICE!

$700.00

Ch. 8835 1929 Ty. I $20 The Birdseye National Bank, Birdseye, Indiana GREAT NAME

$500.00

National Notes

View All

Ch. 8149 1902 $5 PB The Bozeman Waters National Bank of Poseyville, Indiana

$800.00

PMG VF20 Ch. 13759 1929 Ty. II $50 American National Bank of Indianapolis, IN

$550.00

PMG VF25 Ch. 7863 1929 $10 Ty. I The First National Bank of Goodland, Indiana

$400.00

Ch. 1032 1929 $5 Ty. I The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$325.00

RARE Ch. 7174 1902 PB $10 The First National Bank of Williamsburg, Kentucky

$1,500.00

Ch. 8835 1929 Ty. I $20 The Birdseye National Bank, Birdseye, Indiana GREAT NAME

$500.00

PMG Fine 12 Ch. 5845 1882 $5 BB Columbia NB of Indianapolis, IN Quite Scarce!

$1,600.00

PMG VF30 Ch. 7260 1902 $10 PB The First National Bank of Odon, Indiana

$1,300.00

Ch. 8149 1902 $5 PB The Bozeman Waters National Bank of Poseyville, Indiana

$800.00

PMG VF20 Ch. 13759 1929 Ty. II $50 American National Bank of Indianapolis, IN

$550.00

PMG VF25 Ch. 7863 1929 $10 Ty. I The First National Bank of Goodland, Indiana

$400.00

Ch. 1032 1929 $5 Ty. I The First National Bank of Seymour, Indiana

$325.00

RARE Ch. 7174 1902 PB $10 The First National Bank of Williamsburg, Kentucky

$1,500.00

Ch. 8835 1929 Ty. I $20 The Birdseye National Bank, Birdseye, Indiana GREAT NAME

$500.00

PMG Fine 12 Ch. 5845 1882 $5 BB Columbia NB of Indianapolis, IN Quite Scarce!

$1,600.00

PMG VF30 Ch. 7260 1902 $10 PB The First National Bank of Odon, Indiana

$1,300.00